Bigg Boss 20’s physical violence rule is facing its sharpest test of the season. Two separate clashes inside the house have ended in two very different outcomes, and viewers — along with former contestants — are now asking whether the show’s most serious rule is being applied equally to everyone.
The debate, reported by Filmibeat, centres on a simple question: if physical aggression is a red line, should the punishment be the same every time it is crossed?
Quick Facts
- Show: Bigg Boss 20, hosted by Salman Khan; streams at 9 PM on JioHotstar and airs at 10:30 PM on Colors TV.
- Incident 1: Wildcard contestant Nakul Dhull was asked to leave the house after a physical fight with Gullu (Kushal Tanwar). The fight aired on 13 October 2026 and his exit was announced in the episode of 14 October 2026.
- Incident 2: Scout OP pushed Yung DSA during a captaincy task in episode 68. He was not evicted; instead, Bigg Boss handed him season-long punishments.
- Scout OP’s punishments: Nominated for the rest of the season, permanently barred from captaincy, and stripped of immunity and lifeline chances.
- Former contestants speaking out: Delnaaz Irani (season 6) and Arhaan Khan (season 13), in comments reported by Filmibeat.
Nakul Dhull’s Exit: The Case That Set the Benchmark
Nakul Dhull, the content creator known as Mitthu Don, entered Bigg Boss 20 as a wildcard contestant in October 2026. His stay lasted only a couple of days.
According to reports, the trouble began during a discussion involving Qazi Touqeer and Scout OP, when Qazi was heard talking about an earlier incident in which he had spat into Scout’s ear. Nakul confronted Qazi over it, Gullu stepped in, and the argument between Nakul and Gullu turned physical. The two pushed and shoved each other before the other housemates intervened to separate them.
Bigg Boss then called all the contestants into the living room, reprimanded Nakul for resorting to physical violence, and announced that he had to leave the house. Nakul removed his microphone and walked out, showing his middle finger to the housemates as he left. Several housemates, including Mahhi Vij, Kanika Mann, Gullu and Aasif Khan, were seen clapping as the decision was announced, while Qazi Touqeer made a remark about his own role in the chain of events.
Nakul later reacted on social media, posting a picture from inside the house on his Instagram Stories with the line “apne 2 din >>>> unke 100 din”, a pointed reference to his two-day stay.
Some early reports had briefly suggested Nakul might not have been evicted and could continue in the game, but the episode that aired made the outcome clear: Bigg Boss announced his exit as a consequence of the physical altercation. That announcement is what made his case the benchmark against which every later incident in the season is now being measured.
Scout OP and Yung DSA: The Clash That Ended Differently
The second incident came weeks later, during a captaincy task in episode 68, and it involved two housemates who had been close friends since the start of the season.
The task was a robotic chair challenge. One contestant sat on the chair while members of the opposing team tried to make them laugh, cry or lose their temper. During the task, Scout OP tried to provoke Uditi Singh by slightly burning a corner of her family photograph. Yung DSA and Gullu objected, and the disagreement between Scout and Yung escalated into a heated argument. Scout then aggressively pushed Yung, turning a verbal clash into a physical one.
Yung, notably, did not retaliate. He later said he had kept his hands in his pockets to avoid getting physical, and that he did not want to let his mother down by reacting in anger. Bigg Boss stopped the task and separated the two contestants.
This time, however, there was no eviction. Instead, Bigg Boss announced a set of punishments for Scout OP: he would remain nominated for the rest of the season, he would never be eligible to become captain, and he would lose his chances at immunity and at a lifeline. The challenge itself was cancelled.
The difference in outcome was not lost on the housemates. Amrapali Dubey stood in support of Yung and demanded stricter action against Scout, and Yung himself had asked for either eviction or a severe punishment. Salman Khan also took up the matter on the Weekend Ka Vaar stage, questioning Scout on why he had resorted to physical aggression and whether he behaved the same way outside the house. The host praised Yung for the maturity he showed during the incident.
Two Incidents, Two Outcomes
Placed side by side, the two cases are the heart of the debate:
| Nakul Dhull | Scout OP | |
|---|---|---|
| Incident | Physical fight with Gullu after an argument | Pushed Yung DSA during a captaincy task |
| When | Fight aired 13 October 2026 | Episode 68, November 2026 |
| Bigg Boss’s response | Asked to leave the house | Season-long nomination, permanent captaincy ban, no immunity or lifeline |
| Evicted? | Yes | No |
Supporters of the show’s decision argue that the two incidents were not identical. The circumstances were different, the intensity was different, and in Scout’s case the other person involved chose not to escalate. Critics reply that this is exactly the problem: if a rule is a red line, then the severity of each incident should not decide whether the line applies at all.
What Former Contestants Are Saying
Former contestants who have lived inside the Bigg Boss house have now weighed in, and their views add weight to the debate, according to Filmibeat.
Delnaaz Irani, who appeared in season 6, said physical contact should be treated as a clear boundary for everyone, without grading how serious it was. In her view, once outcomes start differing from case to case, the show’s credibility takes a hit. She also spoke about how intense and emotionally demanding life inside the house can be, a reminder that the pressure on contestants is real even when their behaviour cannot be excused by it.
Arhaan Khan, who appeared in season 13, said the makers should ask themselves whether the rules change according to the person involved. His point was that discipline should not depend on a contestant’s popularity or on the storyline the show is pursuing at the time.
Both former contestants, in other words, are making the same argument from different angles: a rule that bends for some housemates and breaks others will always look unfair, whatever the reasons behind each individual decision.
This Is Not the First Time the Rule Has Been Questioned
The debate is not new to Bigg Boss. Physical confrontations in earlier seasons, including season 13 and season 15, also drew sharp reactions from viewers, and in both seasons such incidents led to exits and long-running arguments about whether the makers had acted consistently. That history is part of why the current season’s two cases are being watched so closely: the show has been here before, and the audience remembers what happened last time.
What Is Confirmed and What Is Not
Confirmed: Nakul Dhull left the house after Bigg Boss announced his exit following the physical fight with Gullu. Scout OP pushed Yung DSA during the captaincy task, was not evicted, and received season-long punishments including nomination for the rest of the season and a permanent captaincy ban. Salman Khan questioned Scout about the incident on Weekend Ka Vaar.
Not yet confirmed: There has been no official statement from the makers explaining why the two incidents were treated differently, and no announcement about whether Nakul Dhull will return to the show. Any suggestion that the rules were bent for a particular contestant remains a matter of viewer opinion and debate, not an established fact.
The Question the Show Cannot Avoid
Bigg Boss has always sold itself as a game with rules that apply to everyone equally. The moment viewers start believing that the same offence can end one person’s journey and merely inconvenience another’s, that promise starts to look hollow.
Whether the makers clarify their stand or let the debate run its course, the question raised by the Nakul Dhull and Scout OP cases will not go away on its own: in Bigg Boss 20, is physical violence an automatic exit, or does it depend on who does it? The answer matters, because the credibility of the season’s biggest rule depends on it.
What do you think — should Scout OP have faced the same consequence as Nakul Dhull, or were the two incidents genuinely different? Share your views in the comments.